Captain Tony’s Pizza

Captain Tony's Pizza is a well-established regional pizza chain that has been serving communities across the United States since its founding in 1972. The company began in Buffalo, New York, when Anthony Graci set out to share authentic New York-style pizza with a wider audience. Over the decades, Captain Tony's expanded through franchising, building a presence primarily in the Midwest and Southeast regions.

By the late 1990s, Captain Tony's had grown to over 30 locations, demonstrating its appeal and the loyalty of its customer base. However, as of November 2025, the company operates approximately 15 stores, strategically located in Ohio, Pennsylvania, Michigan, and Florida. This reflects a shift towards a more focused and sustainable growth strategy.

Captain Tony's Pizza is known for its classic menu offerings, which include customizable pizzas, calzones, subs, and salads. The brand emphasizes value and consistency, appealing to families, students, and local residents who enjoy casual dining and takeout options. The stores are typically situated in suburban strip centers and college towns, making them accessible to a diverse clientele.

In recent years, Captain Tony's has concentrated on selective expansion through franchising, particularly targeting suburban and college town markets in the Midwest and Southeast. The company prioritizes second-generation restaurant spaces and inline retail locations, ensuring a flexible store format that can adapt to various retail environments. This approach not only supports existing franchisees but also ensures quality and stability in new ventures.

For commercial real estate professionals, Captain Tony's Pizza presents a stable and recognizable tenant. Its proven track record in second-generation restaurant spaces and adaptable store format make it a compelling option for landlords and brokers looking for reliable foodservice tenants. Captain Tony's enduring presence and strategic growth posture underscore its relevance in the ever-evolving retail landscape.